The Amish aren't Luddites. They don't hate technology. They ask a question no one else asks: 'Will this make our community stronger or weaker?'
Process
New technology appears. Someone wants to use it. Community discussion. Questions: will it destroy family? Create dependency on the outside world? Lead to vanity? Divide the community? If answers are 'no' — allowed (sometimes with restrictions). If 'yes' — forbidden.
Examples
Electricity: no (ties to power grid = world dependency). Propane gas: yes (autonomous). Field tractor: no (replaces horses = skill loss). Stationary tractor at barn (for belt power): yes (some communities). Home phone: no (kills face-to-face conversation). Barn phone (for business): yes (many communities). Smartphone: no (internet = the end).
Logic
Car → can live far from community → weakened bonds → collapse. Electricity → television → internet → pornography, consumerism, alienation. Each step — a logical chain to destroying what matters.
Result
The Amish are the only group that consciously evaluates technology BEFORE adoption. The rest of the world adopts everything new by default, then deals with consequences. Who's wiser?